Culture

When Governance Becomes the Problem: How Board Dysfunction Affects Organisational Culture

18 November, 2026

Poor board governance can damage organisational culture, slow decisions and make it harder for a CEO and executive team to lead. When directors move into operational decisions, the relationship between the Chair and CEO breaks down, or the Board lacks the capability to provide effective oversight, the effects can reach across the organisation.

We talk a lot about poor leadership: CEOs who aren’t performing, executive teams pulling in different directions and leaders whose behaviour creates a difficult culture. But what happens when the problem sits above them, and the Board becomes part of it?

I’ve seen the consequences of poor governance up close. Decisions slow down and priorities shift. Executives become cautious about making calls they should have the authority to make. The CEO spends more time managing upwards than leading the organisation, while employees try to make sense of competing instructions.

Over time, good people become frustrated and leave. Those who stay may find ways to work around the Board, getting things done without triggering another round of questions, delays or interference.

The Board’s influence on organisational culture

Culture starts at the top, and the Board is part of that responsibility.

A good Board brings perspective, challenge and judgement. It holds the CEO accountable while giving them the authority to lead. It also sets clear expectations about which decisions belong to the Board and which belong to management.

Directors need to understand the organisation well enough to ask useful questions and recognise when their involvement is making it harder for people to do their jobs. That takes a willingness to examine their own performance with the same scrutiny they apply to the CEO.

When an executive team isn’t performing, we expect the CEO to address it. When a CEO isn’t performing, we expect the Board to act. But when the Board isn’t performing, who is prepared to raise it, and how willing are Directors to listen?

How a Board review can help

A Board review can help identify where governance, decision-making or director behaviour may be contributing to organisational problems. For it to make a difference, people need to be able to speak honestly, and the findings need to lead to action.

The harder work is being willing to hear that your behaviour, decisions or ways of working may be contributing to the problems you’re asking management to solve.

A question for Directors, Chairs and CEOs

If you’re a Director, Chair or CEO, ask:

Is our Board making this organisation better because we’re here?

If the answer isn’t an immediate yes, that’s probably a conversation worth having.

Exclusive content every week to help you lead with confidence.

Join the hundreds of leaders and changemakers who receive Carole’s short and punchy email each week. 

She’ll guide you on leadership, culture and people & culture trends as well as bring regular interviews with people who you may not have heard from before but who are making the kind of positive impact that can’t be ignored.