Business

The Cost of Calling Culture “Fluffy”

18 November, 2026

Poor workplace culture can affect business performance through employee turnover, lost productivity, management time and customer experience. These costs are often spread across different budgets, which makes them easy to overlook. Looking at culture alongside financial performance can help leaders identify where people problems are creating business costs.

I’ve always found it amusing that we can spend hours in executive meetings discussing revenue, costs, margins and productivity, but the moment someone mentions culture, there’s a risk of eyes glazing over.

Here comes the fluffy stuff.

I get it. Culture can be a vague concept, and I think the way we sometimes talk about it in business hasn’t helped. We’ve turned it into conversations about employee happiness, engagement activities, values posters and making work a great place to be. All important in their own way, although you will never convince me that pizza has ever fixed a dysfunctional executive team.

The commercial cost of workplace culture

Why do we treat culture and business performance as two different conversations?

If a business is losing customers, we want to understand why. If margins are declining, we investigate. If productivity drops, we start asking questions. But when good people keep leaving, teams aren’t working well together or managers are spending half their week sorting out people problems, we don’t always apply the same commercial thinking.

Over the years, I’ve become much more interested in understanding the commercial cost of the things we often put under the heading of culture. The people side matters in its own right, and I’ve also seen how much these issues can cost a business.

The numbers can be confronting. ELMO Software’s 2024 HR Industry Benchmark Report found that the average cost of hiring a new employee in Australia and New Zealand was around $20,000. That’s before factoring in lost productivity, the time a position remains vacant and the effort involved in getting someone new up to speed.

Gallup estimates that replacing a manager or leader can cost around twice their annual salary. Replacing a leader earning $150,000 could therefore cost around $300,000. Gallup also found that 42% of US employees who voluntarily left their jobs believed their manager or organisation could have done something to prevent their departure.

Imagine losing three good people because of a leadership problem everyone knows about but nobody is addressing. That’s an expensive problem to ignore.

Recruitment is only part of the story. Poor communication wastes time, conflict distracts people from their jobs, and frustrated employees can affect what customers experience too.

Bringing people costs into the business conversation

These costs can be difficult to see because they sit in different parts of the business. Recruitment sits in one budget and absenteeism in another. Lost productivity is harder to measure, and I’m not sure anyone’s keeping track of the hours executives spend managing problems that should never have escalated.

Imagine if we added it all up. Perhaps we shouldn’t. It might ruin someone’s weekend.

These days, when I’m talking with CEOs about culture, I’m just as interested in the business numbers as I am in the people numbers. The two are connected.

At your next executive meeting, look beyond the usual financial reports and ask:

  • What are we spending on replacing people who leave?
  • How much management time is being consumed by problems that shouldn’t exist?
  • What are our customers experiencing because of the way our teams work together?

You might not have all the answers. In fact, I’d be surprised if you did. But it would be an interesting conversation, and perhaps a more useful one than debating whether the next staff event should involve pizza or a cheese platter.

If poor culture appeared as a separate expense in your profit and loss statement, would you be paying more attention to it?

Research references: ELMO Software, 2024 HR Industry Benchmark Report; Gallup, “42% of Employee Turnover Is Preventable but Often Ignored”. Figures are indicative. Actual costs vary depending on the role, organisation and location.

Exclusive content every week to help you lead with confidence.

Join the hundreds of leaders and changemakers who receive Carole’s short and punchy email each week. 

She’ll guide you on leadership, culture and people & culture trends as well as bring regular interviews with people who you may not have heard from before but who are making the kind of positive impact that can’t be ignored.